A Message to Personal Trainers and Health Coaches
I know you have good intentions by selling your weight loss programs. At least, I hope you do. So, my intent through the following is not to shame you; rather, I would like to provide information and, perhaps, a new perspective.
Intentional Weight Loss Pursuits (Diets)
Restrictive diets have a 5 percent success rate long term. Meaning, after five years, 95 percent of dieters regain the weight they lost. 1 in 4 dieters develops an eating disorder. Falling just behind opioid use, eating disorders have the second-highest mortality rate of all mental illnesses. You read that correctly — your clients are more likely to develop an eating disorder than they are to maintain weight loss long-term. Additionally, our bodies do not know the difference between planned starvation (dieting) and actual famine. So, when it seems your client “lacks willpower”, consider that it is just their body’s survival response to being starved. Even mental restriction (not physically restricting but feeling guilt about food or planning a diet) can trigger bingeing, or that out-of-control feeling around food.
Before and After Photos
Before and after photos send the message that one body is valued more than the other. While you are praising the body in the ‘after’, you are simultaneously (albeit unintentionally) crapping on the ‘before’ body, anyone who looks like it, and likely your client when they return to that size (again, 5% success rate). If it is TRULY about health, let’s see results like blood work and vital signs, not pounds lost or changes in body shape.
Changing Bodies to Improve Body Image
Body image lives in the brain, so changing what your client sees in the mirror won’t fix it. If someone is struggling with body image, please consider referring them to a therapist. I do want to acknowledge that some people may feel more comfortable or confident in their bodies after they change. I think that is more of a reflection of our society’s value of thinness than an argument for weight loss as a body image tool. OF COURSE we would all have the desire to lose weight when we receive more respect and attention for having a smaller body.
Informed Consent
If you take nothing else, please take this — your clients should have the opportunity to give informed consent. When a doctor prescribes medication, they have to list the potential side effects. If you are going to put your client on a diet, you should give the risks associated (like a 1 in 4 chance of developing an eating disorder) and the efficacy (5%) before they consent.
Your clients will be bombarded especially hard this new year with messages about how they aren’t good enough as they are. Please don’t be another person that contributes to that message.



Comments